Back to Back Issues Page
The "Dirty Thirty" Problems With Employee Performance Reviews! Part 1
April 07, 2011


Employee Rights News You Can Use




The assault on employee rights appears to have taken a turn for the worse. According to David Yamada of The New Workplace Blog, "We’re in the midst of a severe assault on rank-and-file workers, led by anti-labor political and business leaders, and it has entered the realm of attempts to chill speech and artistic expression."

It seems under the state of Wisconsin's public records laws, political groups have filed a records request to search the e-mails of a University of Wisconsin professor who criticized the Wisconsin governor. The governor wants to dismantle the government employees union.

Mr. Yamada states, "Public university professors who are sympathetic to labor protesters may find their e-mails being searched by anti-labor entities who want to discredit, embarrass, or harass them, using public records laws to access their communications." If there was ever a time for career seekers and employees to understand what's happening to the American workplace it's NOW!

As always, I pledge to continue to work, research and pass on to you these changes and how they affect our employment and those we care about. I would like to personally thank my subscribers for allowing me to share our common experiences as job seekers and employees.

**What matters to to help my fellow employee!**

Welcome to this issue of Your Basic Employee Rights eNews! You recently signed up for a subscription at or it was sent to you by a friend. If you no longer wish to receive this newsletter or have a change of address, please use the convenient links at the bottom of this email.

Our overall policy is to deliver important relevant Basic Employee Rights info. We do all the research. There is never a cost or charge.


Filtering software may prevent you from receiving your issue of Your Basic Employee Rights eNews! To ensure that you never miss an email from us, please add us to your whitelist.


Date April 7, 2011

Issue #25


Your Basic Employee Rights Survey results!

I want to thank everyone that participated in my recent survey. It answered some important questions.

(1) What is the #1 workplace issue that concerns or affects you?

(2) How can better address those concerns?

After reviewing the survey results, the #1 workplace issue is....(drum roll ;0) JOB EVALUATIONS!





So let's get to it!



The "Dirty Thirty" Problems With Employee Performance Reviews! Part 1

Warning, your boss does not want you to read about this. I'm really excited about this new performance review series. In researching this aspect of performance appraisals I've gained greater insight and knowledge in how to prepare for them. As you know I love sharing...;0)

A legal study of businesses using job evaluations found most employers could be successfully sued because of how they conducted those performance reviews! The majority of employers hate the employee performance appraisal process. Other research shows the average performance appraisal costs $2000-2500 per employee per year. The vast majority of job evaluations regardless of how well designed fail miserably. There are no state or federal laws requiring job performance evaluations.

So why do our bosses continue to expose themselves and us to the dreaded employee performance evaluation? The only reason that makes sense involves the employer using evaluations to legally justify adverse action and employee termination. However, as I just pointed out most employers are incompetent in the evaluation process for the very reason they keep using them!

That said let's get to the "Dirty Thirty"....oh, by the way there's no specific order, they are all equally important.

Artificial Rating
Guess what, sometimes your boss can and will score you just under qualifying for a raise or a promotion. Many times this is a "pretext" to hide discrimination, retaliation, harassment, bullying, etc. Some managers will also "artificially rate" the other way by giving a higher rating to "pet" employees that should be receive lower ratings.

One Way Only Dialogue
Many supervisors manage by fear and intimidation. They conduct evaluations the same way. Thus, the employee becomes "mute" and pressured to sign the evaluation with no opportunity for feedback.

No second Chance
Once the manager puts on paper their assessment of our performance it generally becomes "law". We can protest and even show the evaluation is in error yet, the employer will usually maintain the evaluation "as is". Of course to maintain inaccurate evaluation(s) isn't smart. This can and will lead to successful employee lawsuits.

Person Appraisal
In my view this is one of the biggest problems with job evaluations. Too many incompetent ill trained managers focus on the "person" instead of the performance. Supervisors will tend to zero in on and make subjective character evaluations of the employee's personality. For example, a manager tells Yancey, "You must be loner. All the other guys come and shoot the breeze with me.

I'm assessing you as needs improvement in the "cooperation with management" section." Yancey however, rates satisfactory or better in the other evaluation sections. The bottom-line of any performance appraisal should be about accomplishments, quantity of work, positive reaction and profitability to the employer.

Alienation From Job Description
Another important factor exposing the weakness of the process is employees being evaluated using criteria that differs significantly from the essential functions on the written job description. Employees being evaluated on things other than the job description can lead to claims of discrimination, low morale, hostility and low productivity.

Reviews Kept In The Shadows
Performance reviews are kept "confidential" or secret. This can embolden some managers to hide discriminatory rating tactics. Therefore, being held accountable for equitable treatment of all employees in the evaluation process is easier to avoid.

No Red Flags
The typical job evaluation has no built in "fix" for the dynamic way job performances can change between evaluation periods. Throw in the possibility of bias from the supervisor it can become a perfect storm for the employee to be "surprised" by an unexpectedly negative review.

Sporadic Appraisals
The process should involve an actual assessment of the performance "as it happens". The primary outcome should be to correct identifiable areas of performance. This is not possible if the evaluation is conducted once a year. There's a whole "universe" of things that may occur in a twelve month period affecting an employee's job performance.

Cowardly Managers
Managers with little or no "backbone" are commonplace. This again speaks to training or lack thereof. Spineless supervisors may give a blanket satisfactory rating to all employees to keep the peace. Even though poor performing employees are obvious to everyone. When there is no differentiation of performance ratings the credibility of the process suffers.

Like Me Evaluations
Human nature says gravitate to those like me. Since managers are human they can and will respond the same way. They will usually evaluate those in common higher than those who are not. We see managers play favorites all the time. This again is a recipe for bias and discrimination.

Well I don't want to bore or put you to sleep if I haven't already ;0)

Stay tuned for;
The "Dirty Thirty" Problems With Employee Performance Reviews! Part 2

All The Best!
From your fellow employee,

Employee Rights Educator, Coach, Trainer, Advocate, Webmaster


Are you a SALARIED or HOURLY employee?

Are you "EXEMPT or "NON-EXEMPT"?

Not Knowing could be COSTING YOU M.ON.EY!!



Finally You CAN OWN internet "Real Estate"!! This is RED HOT!!


Access code: yvoncey


If you need an answer to an employee rights or other legal question, get an answer here F*REE!



Can I Interest You in an Extra $250.00 a Day...?
Legitimate Online Jobs will show you how.



Here's a Special Free Video Series ($97 Value) This resource has been a tremendous help to my blogging efforts.





If you find the info useful please recommend signing up for this newsletter to anyone you know that works for a living, they will thank you for it!

This newsletter is designed for YOU! Let us know what workplace issues concern you the most. Follow this link:












Your Basic Employee Rights eNews is published the first week of the month, 12 weeks per year. From time to time we will publish special features that affect employees in the workplace. We may also offer third party resources that will be of benefit to you our valued subscriber.



Note: Any and all information provided within this Newsletter/Ezine is for educational and general information purposes only. It is NOT INTENDED as legal advice. Please review this specific disclaimer;


Written by Yancey Thomas Jr.


(c)copyright 2011


Back to Back Issues Page